All four traders are sized at 2 NQ (Kian 2026-09-24: apples to apples). "$ per 1 NQ" halves every trader. Drawdown is the deepest fall from a running high, in points per contract. Green cells are the best in each column.
| Trader | Trades | Won | Closed pts | Sum of peaks | Left on table | Kept | Green → red | Avg held (min) |
|---|
Peak = best open profit the trade reached. Left on table = sum of peaks minus what was closed (a hindsight number: nobody sells the exact top). Green → red = the trade showed +20 or more and closed at or below zero.
| Trader | Graded | Direction right | Right but lost | Exited early | Good exit | Stopped, then ran ≥ stop our way | Avg heat 60m | Avg 60m range |
|---|
Direction right: in the 60 minutes after entry price went further our way than against us. Exited early: after the exit it ran 20+ more our way within 30 min. Good exit: it came back 20+ against us after we left. Stopped, then ran ≥ stop our way: a stop-out followed within 30 min by a move our way at least the REAL stop distance (only where the stop is recorded). Every count sits next to its RANDOM TWIN: the same session, side and holding time from a random start minute, graded the same way — read the difference, not the count (most exits see a 20-point move within 30 minutes either way). Heat: the worst it went against us in those 60 minutes.
Each rule is fixed in code and applied to every closed trade's own path, only ever closing EARLIER than the real exit. Points versus the real exits (trades where it fired). Forward evidence only: a rule becomes a change after a registered 10-year test.
| Time | Move | Pts | Rules | Disc | 1h brk | 30m mom | Mirror | Prop |
|---|
| When | Side | Entry | Exit | Pts | Peak | Exit | Tape verdict | Why it went in |
|---|